How to Actually Attract a Music Manager

Why Most Musicians Get This Completely Wrong

Every time a musician tells me they're looking for a manager, I make the same face. Not because getting a manager is a bad idea — it can be one of the best things that ever happens to your career. A good manager takes care of the business side so you can stay focused on creating, storytelling, and not stressing about the bank account. That kind of support is a real lift to your creative productivity.

The problem isn't wanting a manager. The problem is how musicians go about it.

Before we talk about how to attract a manager, we need to talk about the landscape, because too many musicians make huge mistakes here. The worst thing you can do for your music career is sign with an inexperienced manager who claims to be doing things and isn't actually handling anything except sliding into DMs and calling themselves a big-time manager. The reason this is so bad is that you'll assume progress is being made when it isn't. If you listen to interviews with musicians who had tons of buzz and potential that went nowhere, the number one thing they cite is that they trusted someone to handle things when that person wasn't actually doing anything.

I'm not talking about the person you met at a bar who can run an Excel spreadsheet and has met a producer once. I'm talking about an experienced manager with a real roster — someone who is actively breaking acts. And I'm also not talking about someone who managed a successful group in the 90s and has no grasp on how the music business works today. That's just a different way to get nowhere.

Enjoying this? Forward it to a music friend you’d like to be closer to and start a discussion!

Attraction, Not Desperation

The word I want you to pay attention to here is "attract." Most musicians approach this completely backwards — they cold-email big managers, beg for meetings, and wonder why nothing happens. Here's the reality: if you are begging a manager who's established, you are probably not worth managing in their eyes. And even if they do take you on, they will keep you on the back burner indefinitely unless you are already doing the work yourself. You've heard it a thousand times that the music business runs on connections, but what gets left out of that sentence is the part where you actually have to be making moves. The connection is just the door. The moves are what get you through it.

I managed bands for years, and I never said yes to an artist the first time they asked. Or the second, third, fourth, or fifth time. The reason was simple: I would give them advice, watch what they did with it, and treat that as a trial run before committing to anything. Were they going to hustle? Were they going to listen? Were they going to make smart decisions? That tells you everything about whether the working relationship is going to go anywhere. No manager worth their rate wants to babysit someone who has no idea what they're doing. The last thing a successful person in this business wants is a ship full of panicked people who don't know how to get to shore.

The energy that actually attracts a manager is the opposite of that. It's showing up with a clue. It's making a manager feel like they'd be joining a team that's already moving — not building one from scratch for you.

Three Ways Managers Actually Find Artists

Through their existing network. The most common way an artist ends up on a great manager's roster is through an introduction — from a producer, a director, or more often, another artist already on that manager's roster. Someone in the manager's orbit says, "You need to pay attention to this person." That gets you on their radar. Then they watch. They want to see you making moves. Getting the introduction is step one — sustaining attention after it is step two, and that's the part most people fumble.

Through word of mouth and scene scouts. A manager's job is largely to talk to people all day and make connections, which means they're constantly hearing about who's getting a buzz in a given scene or micro-genre. A lot of that information comes from what you might call scouts — the young movers and shakers who have their ears to the ground. These are the people scouring SoundCloud and Bandcamp and music blogs, looking for the next interesting thing. They're watching who's showing up on smaller playlists, who's generating early adopter excitement, and whose name keeps coming up in conversations. Consistent Sustained Promotion (CSP) is a huge reason why this matters — it keeps you top of mind with these people and keeps your name in their mouths when they're on those calls with managers.

Through data. Getting on viral music charts, trending on discovery platforms, or landing a big playlist placement will absolutely get a manager's attention. This one tends to feel more out of your control than the other two, but it's worth mentioning because it's real.

What to Do When You Get the Meeting

Let's say the introduction happened, and you've gotten through the door. A crucial detail: they are probably not going to sign you on the spot. What you're doing at this meeting is increasing the odds that they eventually do. There's a difference between showing up and talking about what you need versus showing up and explaining exactly why you're about to pop off.

The data piece matters a lot here. The music business runs on data today in a way it never used to. Every person you're trying to impress is looking at numbers. So come with something — a growth trend, a chart position, a streaming uptick, anything that demonstrates you understand the game and are tracking your own progress. It doesn't have to be massive numbers. It just has to show growth and demonstrate that you know how to read what's happening and explain it to someone else. The most important skill in getting doors open in this business — after having good music — is knowing how to tell people something about your music that gets them excited. If you're not sure how to do that, it's worth spending real time on it.

You also don't have to have some wild, unique story. You just have to know what makes you special and be able to communicate it in a way that creates some excitement. Even something that isn't inherently flashy can land well if you can sell it. If you make massive bangers and you know it, say that — clearly and confidently.

Following Up Is Where Most People Give Up

Here's the biggest mistake musicians make after a meeting: they don't get a contract, they assume they were rejected, and they fall off. This isn't rejection. This is the process. You have to show you're dedicated, because dedication is exactly what managers are looking for — especially in an era where people are just as happy to blow up as a fitness influencer or a YouTube personality. Music managers are in the music game specifically. They want to see that you are too, consistently and over time.

The move is to keep sending updates. Every time you hit a meaningful milestone — a new release, a playlist placement, a strong data point — send a personal email to every potential team member you've met. Not a blast, not a newsletter. Personal emails, every single time, to every relevant contact, until your team is full. That practice builds momentum and keeps you in people's minds in the right way.

Bartees Strange is one of the best real-world examples of this entire approach done right. We did a full episode about everything he did to get where he is — it's linked below and worth your time if you want to see this play out in practice.

The Short Version

Attracting a manager isn't a hack. There's no cold email script that unlocks this. The way it actually works is that you make consistent, smart moves, you get introduced through people already in the ecosystem, you sustain attention and build buzz among early adopters, and when you finally get the meeting, you show up with data and a clear sense of what makes you worth betting on. Then you follow up. And keep following up.

Do those things and the manager conversation becomes significantly easier — because you'll actually be worth having it.